Unlike some other reviewers, I found these boots difficult to put on, at least the first time. Once I got them on, however, they felt perfect. The instep is rather snug, but except for the problem of getting my foot past the tight spot into the footbed, I like it that way. The leather used for the shaft and instep is very soft, so the instep feels snugly wrapped rather than squeezed. The leather on the shoe portion is sturdier. These boots are cool looking and comfortable. I'm going to invest in a shoe horn.I bought a second pair of these based on comfort, quality, price, and color. I can wear these all day. No break-in period was needed. I just unpacked them, put them on, went to work and shopping. The leather is soft and supple. I bought a 1/2 size up so I could wear extra thick socks in the winter and because my feet are just a little wider than a medium. These were such a good pair of boots that I bought the second pair for after the first pair wears out. For $51 for a $270 pair of leather Clarks boots, you'll never find a better deal!!!!I did not like the color of this boot it was sorta mix match the foot vs the shaftThey look exactly like the picture, there is a sheen to them. I normally wear 9 1/2 and the 91/2 in these fit perfectly. My feet are on the narrow side and so is the toe box of these boots. People with a wider foot may want to go up a size. I love them!Had tried on in a Clark's store but didn't want to spend that much money! Found a bit cheaper on Amazon. Absolutely love this boot! Am a teacher so on my feet all day!! Wore 2 days in a row with no break-in at all! Very stylish and great with leggings or skinny jeans. Got lots of compliments!!!These are the most comfortable boots I have ever had. Have them now in both colors - soft leather uppers, easy to pull off and on, and so stylish. The overall detail is above the average Clark's boots. Wore them 12 hours the very first day. Cute with long skirts or skinny pants/leggings.Love these boots. Super comfy, easy to get on and off. Stylish but practical. Runs true to size, average width. My only comment is that my zippers are not functional. They look like they should be, but neither moves. It doesn't matter, you don't need to unzip them, they slide easily on and off with the zipper closed.Nice, but too large & wide. Cost me over $16 in shipping & then additional shipping costs to return. So I lost approximately $32 just for ordering!!!!